| I've been in rock and roll all my life and I'm well | | | | high, up to 11 minutes in length without resorting |
| aware that The Rolling Stones have been called | | | | to an overly repetitive chorus. I know from |
| the best rock and roll band. Don't get me wrong | | | | Robert's solo work after Led Zep that he also |
| because I love Mick and the Stones, and the | | | | uses unusual tonalities in his writing, but even |
| Beatles were my major musical influence, but | | | | without actually knowing this I would have to |
| here's why I think that Led Zeppelin is the best | | | | assume that due to Jimmy Page being an erupting |
| rock and roll band of all time: | | | | fountain of brilliant guitar work, the |
| BEST PLAYERSFirst of all, John Bonham was the | | | | majority of the non-vocal music creation came |
| best rock and roll drummer ever to walk the face | | | | from Jimmy. The Beatles certainly deserve abject |
| of this planet, and that's an informed opinion | | | | worship for John and Paul's creative songwriting |
| coming from a former professional drummer. John | | | | ability, no question about that. Certainly Mick and |
| played drums unlike anyone else ever did, still | | | | Keith wrote a slew of classic, historic and truly |
| does, or ever will, and that fact is continually | | | | memorable rock songs, but the very nature of |
| demonstrated in the astounding breadth and | | | | their comparatively simple rock and roll structure |
| depth of his recorded work. He had complete | | | | and basic similarity to each other in terms of using |
| independence in all four limbs, he slammed his | | | | major and minor chord progressions, simple and |
| drums harder than anyone else, and he did it with | | | | basic rock and roll rhythms, and verse/chorus |
| speed and total precision, never once dropping the | | | | bridge approach defines them as being less |
| beat. His beats were were innovative and | | | | innovative when compared to Robert and |
| creative, and John was never stuck in simple | | | | Jimmy.SUM TOTAL OF BRILLIANT WORKHere |
| grooves. His fills were innovative, creative, | | | | they outdistance The Stones because most of |
| complex, and technically brilliant, he knew when to | | | | the Stones' albums have "fillers", which are songs |
| keep it relatively simple (i.e. Kashmir), but he was | | | | that do not hit the same intense high that got |
| always in the stratosphere of drumming. And to | | | | slammed in all their best ones. However, I'd like to |
| top that all off, John created a giant drum sound | | | | say that I don't think either Mick or Robert is |
| which is unique. It inspired a host of imitators who | | | | capable of recording anything short of a brilliant |
| were able to | | | | vocal. The Beatles actually exceed Led Zep in |
| imitate the sound of his snare drum, but only | | | | terms of numbers of great albums that constitute |
| with a simple backbeat. At the time that Led Zep | | | | a greater body of brilliant and uniquely innovative |
| was formed, Jimmy Page could have gotten any | | | | work that literally broke new musical ground with |
| drummer in the world to play with him, and he | | | | every single song they recorded. The Beatles |
| chose John. There's not one single drummer alive | | | | were simply The Beatles, and they were the |
| or dead who can begin to touch John's power, | | | | most creative rock and roll band ever, from being |
| creativity, speed, precision, and technical brilliance. | | | | the best singers and songwriters ever right down |
| I've heard that Jimmy still feels the same way | | | | to their individual charm and charisma. But without |
| about John as I do.Secondly, Jimmy Page has | | | | denigrating their gorgeous, sensitive and original |
| always been one of the best rock guitarists ever, | | | | style of playing, what they recorded is not the |
| right from his earliest days as a session player | | | | heavy type of rock and roll that either the |
| and the beginning of his real public stardom in the | | | | Stones or Led Zep played. George, Paul and John |
| Yardbirds. I believe that Jimmy is the most | | | | were all brilliant and creative guitarists, but |
| brilliantly prolific of all the great rock and roll | | | | because they did not improvise on stage, they |
| guitarists. I suspect that Jimmy would agree with | | | | were not really master guitarists. I love and |
| me that Jimi Hendrix was the one true genius of | | | | respect Ringo as both a person and as a very |
| guitar because he came from another galaxy in | | | | creative drummer who mastered the art of drum |
| terms of his sound and his use of feedback. But | | | | sounds. He has his own unmistakable Ringo style |
| unfortunately, Jimi died and we will never know | | | | for both, but he's not really a master drummer in |
| how much further he would have progressed. | | | | the sense of being able to play with great speed |
| When I listen to Jimmy's solos using the violin | | | | and dexterity. I'm talking about 9 Led Zep albums |
| bow, I get the urge to put him on the same | | | | chock full of brilliant and intensely high songs - I |
| pedestal as Hendrix and wonder which galaxy | | | | don't know how many hours of great rock and |
| they both came from. As a songwriter, Jimmy | | | | roll listening that is. There's not a single weak |
| used his superior ability to play lead guitar to | | | | track among all that work, and there's simply no |
| create actual song structure. Led Zep's songs use | | | | question that they consistently broke new ground |
| not one or two of Jimmy's incredibly powerful, | | | | musically. Their debut album is still the best one of |
| complicated and unbelievably SEXY riffs in each | | | | all time (including Cream's), and Coda, their "swan |
| song, but there are four, five or more riffs in | | | | song" is equally perfect.STAGE PRESENCELed Zep |
| some songs. Jimmy's riffs differ from each other | | | | was there when the concept of "rock and roll |
| within each song, and also from song to song. His | | | | star" was still evolving. I will grant that the Stones |
| lead guitar playing can be HARD and sexy, he can | | | | at least deserve honorable mention as the best |
| be sensitive and beautiful, and he can be | | | | rock and roll band but it's mostly because of their |
| technically brilliant, all in the very same | | | | impressive touring record and Mick's superstar |
| song.Thirdly, John Paul Jones is a bass player who | | | | stage presence with his ability to put on a great |
| attained a level of brilliance comparable to Paul | | | | show every single time he appears. And he's still |
| McCartney. Just like McCartney, John could play | | | | doing it at age 60 for goodness sake! My point |
| beautiful "melodic" bass (i.e. "Ramble On"), he could | | | | isn't that Led Zep necessarily had the best stage |
| play as fast as it gets, but he also knew when to | | | | presence, just that they did have a true rock star |
| keep it simple and just hold down the bottom | | | | sexual aura.I could go on about Jimmy Page's |
| although I think he was incapable of doing that | | | | abilities as a producer, and there are other |
| without utter sophistication. No one at all can | | | | aspects to their greatness like the length of time |
| touch those two on bass, and John also played | | | | they were together without a change of band |
| consistently brilliant keyboards - piano, organ and | | | | members. And the life they actually led as |
| synthesizer. The intricate way in which he wove | | | | archtypical wild rock and roll bad boys equals the |
| his bass guitar playing into, through, and | | | | life led by the Rolling Stones in intensity, if not |
| underneath Jimmy's guitar playing is nothing short | | | | length. Both bands are perfect examples on an |
| of perfection itself.And last but not at all least, | | | | artistic level of what I call FORM = CONTENT, |
| Robert Plant had an incredibly high vocal range, | | | | which in this case means that these two rock and |
| emotionally as well as in terms of octaves. Just | | | | roll bands personified the rock and roll life.In |
| like Dylan was for his own music, Robert's voice | | | | conclusion, the above four categories do enough |
| was perfect for Led Zep's music and there's no | | | | to fully qualify Led Zeppelin for my not-so-humble |
| other singer who could possibly have fit in. As a | | | | award. There will never be another rock and roll |
| professional singer, I'm knocked out by Robert's | | | | band to approach the stratospheric musical |
| vocals on both a technical and an emotional level. | | | | heights that Led Zep reached. The Recording |
| Robert understood the concept of using his voice | | | | Industry Association of America, who has the |
| like a musical instrument, creating fascinating | | | | correct statistics, lists Led Zeppelin as the third |
| sounds without using lyrics. And Robert co-wrote | | | | best selling musical act/artist in history. The |
| with Jimmy too. A lot of the time you can't | | | | Beatles are first, with 166.5 million albums sold in |
| understand his lyrics and I've heard that was | | | | the USA alone, Elvis is second with 117.5 million, |
| Robert's intent because just like Mick Jagger, all he | | | | and Led Zep is third with 106 million. I think it's |
| cared about at that time was that you connect | | | | very significant that those statistics are becoming |
| with the emotion and the energy in the totality of | | | | geometrically times greater than the number of |
| the music. But when you can get the lyrics (like in | | | | albums that they sold during their performance |
| Stairway to Heaven, their tribute to Janis Joplin), | | | | lifetimes. What has happened |
| you find a great piece of poetry. And on top of all | | | | and is happening is that the young people of |
| that, Robert had the best "oooh yeahs" in the | | | | today are discovering them in droves because |
| business!CREATIVE SONGWRITINGHardly | | | | they are coming of age sexually and they |
| anybody has ever covered Led Zep songs for | | | | recognize and connect with the most powerful |
| very good reasons. Their song structure is based | | | | musical example of that sexual power. They are |
| on their vastly superior playing abilities and there's | | | | buying their CD's, shirts, posters and other |
| no one who can actually play what they played. | | | | memorabilia. And frankly, I'm thrilled.Peter Cross is |
| I'm talking about songs that are not based on | | | | a former professional drummer and a singer |
| simple chords like all other rock and roll is. Jimmy | | | | songwriter/producer/Web Master who was |
| and Robert based their songs on Jimmy's riffs and | | | | among the first to put music on the Internet in a |
| on his chordal tonalities that to this day stand | | | | downloadable format in 1996. His web site is very |
| alone as being unique. I'm also talking about length | | | | entertaining and at 206 pages, it may be the |
| of songs that maintain a constant and intense | | | | largest music artist web site on the Internet. |