Learn about medieval weapons


ehcg.org keyword stats



Most current MSN search phrases:

swordsmen jaime spears.com
ancient fishing
money how to make a grape trellis
medieval longswords
making laminated maple longbows we bow downlyrics
orchid world war I weaponary
ANTIQUE STONE DRILL swords
horoscope ceremony
uniforms  

Myth of the Sword

The Myth of the Invincible Sword Nearlyand cumbersome. The tang of the sword,
all cultures throughout history havethe blade's extension into the handle,
been subject to the myth of thereceives most of the impact when
all-powerful sword. China's history isparrying and can be prone to breaking.
filled with legendary swords andMany styles of the sword offered little
swordsmen some of whom even rose to thehand protection and so the hand of a
levels of gods. The Japanese have theswordsman was a primary target. To
legendary Samurai with their worldcounter this, some swords were built
famous katana, often referred to as thewith elaborate basket-like guards to
Samurai sword. Cossack, Moor, and otherprotect the hand. There are accounts of
Muslim cultures are often remembered asthe basket-hilt broadsword of Scottish
mounted, saber-wielding warriors. Inhighlander fame having to be pried off
Western Europe the medieval knights wereof the Highlander's hand after battle
in no way an exception to the sworddue to its collapsing under the pressure
culture. The sword's symbolicof enemy blows. The sword is
connection to the heraldic nobilitycomplicated to learn, time consuming to
remains to this day, although inmake, and generally an expensive arm.
ceremonial form only. For most culturesIn medieval Europe, a single-handed
around the world, the sword still holdsbroadsword could cost as much as 25,000
a position of reverence. I have dueleddollars by today's standards. The
and sparred with and against swords forJapanese katana was, in its own fashion,
many years and yet I am still amazedan equally high-priced weapon. One can
when the first words out of almost everysee the obvious reasons why, during
new student are, 'I want to learn how toEastern and Western sword histories, the
fight with a sword.' I explain thatweapon was really more of a class and
unless your armored and riding a horsepower symbol than a mainstream weapon
whenever the sword is pitted againstfor war. There is a Japanese house code
nearly any other ancient weapon of equalthat states "Do not yearn for katanas
length or longer inevitability it comesand tantos created by famous masters. A
up wanting. However, the invinciblekatana or tanto worth 10,000 pieces can
sword myth is so deeply ingrained inbe defeated by 100 yari (spears) each
human culture that such warnings arecosting a 100 pieces. It is better to
rarely heeded, and predictably, thepurchase 100 spears and arm 100
sword becomes most students' firstspearmen, in this way you can defended
focus. The sword's true combat natureyourself in time of war." (Toshikage
can only be revealed through theJushichikajo, 1480) Today the
handling of the real thing, authenticsword and Samurai have nearly become the
replicas, and precise training weaponssame word. Yet during the height of the
that are meticulously designed forage of the Samurai, the bow, naginata,
proper accuracy and use. With the aideand spear were the main focus for war.
of such training tools the myth of theThe bow is found in the earliest history
sword can be unlocked, not just from aof Samurai warfare and the Yari-Samurai,
historical approach but from a hands-onelite spearmen, mounted or on foot, were
approach as well. Sadly, often schoolsamong the highest valued warriors in a
do not follow an accuracy policy withwarlord's army. The katana was more
training weapons or when sparring withoften used as a backup weapon and for
weapons. This is one reason why therepersonal ritualized dueling. In most
are so many misconceptions about genuinecultures during the age of battlefield
sword combat. The Japanese sport ofdueling, duels were fought on horseback
kendo is commonly believed to be awith bows or lances. If the warrior
martial art based on dueling withlost either of those weapons, he then
katanas. Nothing could be further fromused his sword as a last ditch effort to
the truth. The two are as different assave or take his life. Around the same
kickball and baseball. The kendotime the drafted peasant soldier of the
sparring sword called a shinai is alate nineteenth century came into full
straight sparring sword meant to be aforce, the sword, due to its impractical
safe representation of the katana. Thisfunctions on the battlefield, was
very light weapon averages anywhere fromeventually reduced to an ornamental
35" to 47" in length and is made ofsymbol of authority. During the Second
several straight strips of bamboo boundWorld War the ancient Samurai sword that
together with leather. With thewas made using the secrets of a holy
exception of the lengths, the balanceswordsmith still remained among the
and design of this sparring tool fromupper class, but the sword for the
its tip to handle holds absolutelyaverage officer was a 1933 mass-produced
nothing in common with the Samurai'sweapon. This 1933 version was designed
curved katana. The shinai blade isso that the older traditional katana
straight and its handle is long, round,blade could fit into the handle and
and wrapped in a soft leather sheath.replace the standard contemporary blade.
The katana blade is curved and itsBecause of the entertainment industry
handle is long and somewhat egg shapedfrom ancient times to the present, the
but a little more flat along the sides,myth of the swordsman's abilities has
and it is braided. The hits and pointsalways been far beyond any true feat of
scored in sport kendo have more inreal swordsmanship. The western
common with European cudgel play orbroadsword has followed the same path as
fencing than with a katana duel. Pointsthe eastern swords, only it has been
are most often scored with snapping hitseven further reduced into a simplistic,
as opposed to the drawing cuts that comeshining hip-hanger used only for parade.
naturally with a curved blade. ThoughThe Chinese straight sword has not
snap cuts are also a part of theescaped this symbolism either. It has
katana's arsenal they are not a staplebeen reduced to a lightweight flimsy
of attack as in kendo. A closershow piece far more suitable for fast
representation would be sparring withacrobatic Wu-Su routines then actual
curved wooden bokkens, which arecombat. What the general public has
considerably more accurate reproductionsbeen led to believe almost entirely
of the katana and were the traditionalthrough the media is that the sword was
training weapon of the classical Bushi.the most powerful dueling weapon of all
The bokken offers a close though nottimes. There are many reasons why the
completely accurate representation of asword could not actually hold this
bladed katana duel and was often usedtitle. First as mentioned is reach;
for dueling as a replacement for realsecond, arch versus thrust; third and
swords. Miyamoto Musashi, arguably onemost important, exposure. To better
of the greatest swordsmen in Japaneseexplain the realities of sword combat
history, by his own account won severaland the troubles a swordsman would have,
duels against katanas with a bokken. Asconsider facing a spearman with a sword.
with shinais, the same problem arisesTo start the swordsman's troubles, the
from modern and the ancient westernspearman need only keep the swordsman
forms of cudgel play. The rattan orthe distance of a spear thrust away. In
other wooden forms of broadswords aredoing so, the swordsman is put in danger
bulkier, unbalanced, poorly weighted,of spear attacks while his target, the
and often have no obvious flat side tospearman, remains out of reach. Being
parry with. Because of these designout of reach of the attacks of his
flaws cudgel play can only be consideredopponent, the spearman has many
a sport not a form of combat. Oneadvantages added to his hopes of
should not compare these sport-relatedself-preservation. A spear, or even a
styles of combat to the real thing. Alance of ten feet or less, can both cut
comparison cannot accurately be made ifand thrust like a sword and so deliver a
for no other reason than the sparringvariety of attacks without fear of
weapons are so dramatically removed inimmediate counterattack. For the
weight, shape, and design from theswordsman to survive, he needs to close
weapons they are supposed to replicate.the distance on his opponent while
When a student reaches a high enoughtrying to ward off thrusts and cuts from
sword skill to spar against other typesthe attacking spear. The spearman need
of weapons, the design flaws of theonly keep attacking while retreating or
sword as a singly competitive weaponcircling a few steps if necessary. This
become painfully obvious. It is notis comparable to a man with an empty
long after this realization that theeighteenth-century musket fighting a
sword student fades out of the pictureten-pace duel against a man with a colt
along with dreams of becoming anrevolver. Unless an act of God occurs,
invincible swordsman. The fewthe musketeer is in for hard times. The
persistent sword students who remainnext problem is the issue of arch versus
quickly find the value of an addedthrust. Everyone has seen a movie where
weapon to their free hand. Shields,the hapless spearman comes charging in
maces, flails, daggers, or other swordswith a stiff-armed thrust at the hero,
become the new order of training. Withwho is always a swordsman, who jumps to
a little more sparring, the studentthe side and chops the oncoming spear in
begins to see the ultimate truth behindtwo. This is a perfect example of the
the myth of the sword. Even with themythological power of the arching sword
aid of another weapon, it is a verystroke in its full absurdity. If the
difficult task for a swordsman to defeatswordsman were to attempt a wasted
longer-reaching weapons. When amotion like trying to cut the assaulting
swordsman is matched up against a weaponspear in two, it would be an ill-fated
that is longer and therefore holdsmove for two reasons: it seriously
greater reach capabilities thatexposes the swordsman to a
swordsman's chance of survival dropscounterattack, and it is an almost
dramatically. Without the aid of aimpossible cut to make. It is one thing
companion weapon, even a highly skilledto cut in two a shaft stuck firmly in
swordsman finds it difficult to defeatthe ground, it is another thing entirely
lesser skilled opponents with longer-to try and cut in two a free-floating
reaching weapons. The sword mastershaft that deflects on impact. Try
Miyamoto Musashi, victor of sixtyhanging a spear-like shaft in the air by
life-and-death encounters, was in aattaching a rope to the butt of the
famous duel of record against theshaft and attaching another rope at a
long-swordsman, Sasaki Kojiro. Kojirohalfway point. Then try to chop that
called his sword 'clothes pole' becauseshaft in two with a single or several
of its unique design: a long, straight,strokes. When you are through shaking
blade quite the contrary to itsyour head, all those great movies will
contemporary, the curved katana. Whenbe ruined forever. The easily imagined
Musashi dueled Kojiro, he was notresults of this simple test are exactly
wielding a curved katana of his own orlike the real results of such a cut.
even using his famous two-sword style.The reader can see just how unlikely
Instead he wisely used a large, carvedperforming that cut actually is. Some
boat oar to defeat his opponent. ThisArthurian legends claimed the sword,
boat oar gave Musashi two very importantExcalibur, could cut a boulder in two as
advantages: first he did not have tothough the rock was made of butter.
concern himself with the angles of hisStrangely, no sword culture can deny
cuts, and second, he did not have tohaving myths of an equal nature to that
worry about parrying with his sword andof Excalibur's. There is also a
having it destroyed by a big boat oar.Japanese legend of a katana so sharp
It is no mystery why Musashi won thisthat when it was left stuck in a stream,
duel. When two duelers meet and arefloating leaves were not sliced in-two
equal or even close to equal in skills,by it but actually purposely avoided the
the odds go to the dueler with thesword's edge. Legends of this nature
technological advantage. I know thehave always led the populous into
entertainment industry would have usbelieving that in the realm of edged
believe otherwise, but when it comes toweapons, the sword holds full royalties
sparring or dueling with weapons, youon slicing and chopping abilities. This
can't change the math behind the designis simply not true regarding personal
of the weapon, techniques, and thecombat. All of the elite
movement the weapon's nature requires.warrior-based cultures knew and used the
George Silver, an accomplished dueleradvantages of thrusting and slicing with
and prizefighter who wrote two treatisesa spear as well as other long-reaching
on combat in 1599, Brief Instructionsweapons. The difficulties of getting
and Paradoxes of Defense pointed out inpast that deadly reaching spear would be
his works, and I paraphrase, "He whono small task for a swordsman. In
moves in the least amount of space andaddition to this reach advantage, even a
time, moves ahead of his opponent and somoderately skilled spear fighter can
stays out of harm while being able todeliver several thrusts or cuts to an
inflect harm." To make Silver's pointoncoming swordsman before that sword can
consider the story of David and Goliath.reach its target. History has shown us
Goliath is unrivaled on the battlefieldthat one of those many spear cuts would
and no Israelite can stand against himbe to either to the swordsman's lead
in single combat. He holds severalknee, hand, arm, or foot. A good hit to
advantages over his opponents: he isany of these areas would end the
stronger and so can attack and defendswordsman's attack promptly. A common
with more power than his opponent; he ismisjudgment is that a large portion of a
taller which gives him the ability toweapon's edge needs to strike the
both outreach and outstride hissurface to do any real damage. An edge
opponents; and he is undefeated, whichneed only penetrate the depth of three
gives him a psychological advantage overfingers in the right areas of the human
his opponents. Goliath would likelyanatomy to be a fatal hit or lead to
have been armored and have theone. Though the stroke to the knee is
contemporary weapons of the times,not a fatal blow, worldwide
bronze or leather armor, a bronze orarchaeological finds from battle sites
wicker shield, spear, and according toinvolving ancient weapons have
legend a great sword. On the otherconsistently shown that such a wound led
side of the dueling scale is the boy,to a final lethal blow. In these
David. David is a mere sheep-herdingarchaeological digs, large percentages
child, not even a warrior in theof the fallen were first struck at the
traditional sense. David's only weaponbend of the knee, or other exposed
is a sling. It would appear that theappendages, and then delivered a fatal
scales tip heavily in favor of Goliath,blow while they lay prostrate from the
but a more detailed look reveals thefirst injury. By studying the results of
opposite. The sling is a formidablemany years of full-contact dueling with
weapon in this realm of single combat,training and blunted weapons, I have
especially single combat on an openrarely found this cut to a charging
battlefield that offers room toopponent's knee, ankle or foot to fail.
maneuver. Bearing in mind the nature ofAn equally successful tactic is
the ground in the Middle East, Davidthrusting into the opponent's oncoming
also had plenty of rocks to choose fromfeet. When infantry used swords and
while maneuvering. Out of necessity asshields against lance-carrying cavalry,
a sheepherder, he would have been athe results nearly always ended in
well-practiced slinger and skilled atdisaster for the foot soldier. When
keeping predators away from the herdfoot soldiers replaced swords with
with endless days to spend flingingspears and lances, the disaster fell on
rocks with his sling to pass the timethe heavy cavalry. It was so effective
away. With those skills he could havethat infantry pike units became the
continually launched a rock at Goliathstandard for hundreds of years. Pike
for every other step Goliath did or didunits were not removed from the
not take, all the while staying out ofbattlefield until the advent of
reach of Goliath's weapons; thusefficient firearms sporting bayonets,
fulfilling Silvers' recipe for victory.which was not the demise of the pole
Due to its translation through time, theweapon but rather a merger of pike and
story has led us to believe that David'sgun. When the sword is pitted against a
sling was both laughable and ultimatelyspear, the swordsman also has to
a shock to Goliath. Neither would beovercome the issue of too much exposure.
true, the sling has been around for aCombat manuscripts of old break the
long time and was a commonplace weaponsword down into sections depending on
in early biblical warfare. It isthe type of sword. The first third of
reasonable to believe that Goliath wasthe blade from its tip down was for
defeated because of the nature of thecutting, the next third was for soft
weapon's reach, the terrain conditions,parries, and the final third above the
and the psychological effects of thehand guard was for heavy parries and
whole scheme of things, i.e., thecoming to grips with your opponent. The
undefeated war giant versus aold masters from the East and West also
sheep-herding boy with everybodywrote that the preferred method of
watching. How much time would Goliathdefense with a sword was simply to avoid
spend hiding behind his shield from ayour opponent's attacks physically and
boy while the Philistine and Israelithrough footwork. This method was
armies watched? Let us assume thatpreferred over jeopardizing your sword's
Goliath, like every other solider duringcutting edge and its structural
biblical warfare, has seen a sling inintegrity by using it to fend off blows
action before, as opposed to the commonfrom other weapons. With exceptions,
belief that he thought it laughable andthe sword length averages from 20 to 42
fell victim to his overconfidence.inches. On the contrary, the smallest
Goliath could hide behind his shield andbattlefield spear is around six feet in
try to close within sword range, but inlength with a shaft designed for warding
order to hit David he has to be able tooff blows from other weapons. The
see him. When Goliath exposes his faceswordsman must also overcome the limited
to look, David only needs to time hisrange of his defense, referring not only
next rock for impact into that exposedto the sword's reach but also the axis
moment. It is nearly impossible towith which one can parry and so defend
successfully time a parry against athe body. Take into account the
missile weapon launched at close range.mechanics of the human body and the
The smaller the projectile, David'slength, manner, and design of the weapon
rock, the more difficult it is to see,being used. The nature of the sword
calculate its speed, and accuratelycreates a problem when defending above
react to defending the target area ofor below the waist. The problem is to
its destination. Also added to David'sdefend one's body above or below one
advantages is he can launch his rocksmust, by the nature of the sword, expose
continually. With the sling David canthe opposite of what is defended. This
follow a familiar formula: he can attackis true with all weapons but to a higher
repeatedly while remaining out of reachdegree with sword and similar weapons.
of his opponent's assaults. At bestThe pole arm offers considerably more
Goliath would have had the opportunityoptions. By tipping the weapon
for one spear throw at David, but againvertically, horizontally, or diagonally
at the cost of over exposing himself toout from the body, one can readily
David's faster sling attacks. Afterdefend and strike from any axis of the
that spear throw its back to swordbody. The pole arm fighter does not
range. Whatever tactic Goliath used weeven have to resort to this guard until
all know the result of it. Musashithe swordsman gets in close enough to be
used a similar technique to David'sa threat. The swordsman, on trying to
against the chain and sickle fighterclose, has to defend too much exposed
Shishido Baiken. Again, rather than usearea and so is subject to attack at
his sword and face the extra challengesseveral areas on his body. To a large
that comes with it, Musashi opts to makedegree this is why the shield was
a close range throw of his tanto, adeveloped. In most cultures, the shield
Japanese dagger which hits and kills hiswas developed for war and not dueling.
unsuspecting opponent. In the West, oneThe shield was designed to be part of a
seldom hears of duels pitting a swordwall of shields used as a defensive
against another type of weapon. Inbattle tactic as demonstrated by the
Europe it was considered an unfairfront lines of a Greek phalanx, the
advantage to mix weapons during duels.Roman turtle formation, and the Viking
The European duel was as often a mattershield wall. In a duel or single
of righting wrongs and maintaining honorcombat, the shield is used in a
as it was about issues of martialconsiderably different manner than in a
skills. In the East reasons for duelingmelee or mass melee. Regardless of how
ranged from matters of honor to testingit is used, the shield can only
martial skills. One dueled witheffectively protect one side of the body
whatever weapon one specialized in, andduring a charge and so forces the
it was believed if you were a warriorwielder to defend his opposite side with
you should be able to defend yourselfthe sword. Because of the leverage that
with your weapon regardless of what yourcan be placed behind a thrusting or
opponent was using, the only true rulesweeping pole attack, the sword and its
was to win. This is a much harder testwielding arm cannot compete with the
of skills than to be protected by theimpact of an oncoming pole weapon As
equality of weapons. Knowing this, onementioned earlier, this is especially
must question why dueling with thetrue when a sweeping spear cut or a
katana did not reach its peak untilthrust is delivered to the swordsman's
after the age of elite Samurai warriors.stressed knee, ankle, or foot. Such an
After the dismantling of the Samuraiattack forces the swordsman to bring the
class, an action that turned the oncetip of his sword down; the arm position
proud warrior class into living archiveswould be the equivalent of completely
of an age gone for good. During thisemptying a drinking mug gripped in your
later era, most Japanese field weaponshand. Doing this simple motion the
became obsolete and where impractical toreader can see how the position is both
carry in public. With a major declineawkward and weak; furthermore, the
in the use of most battlefield weapons,position also exposes the upper torso.
the time for the sword to shine was atThe lower guard that could be used
hand. The katana became the Samurai'sexposes even more of the swordsman's
last symbolic hold on an ancient warriorbody. A high or low, well-timed thrust
system soon to be completely outdated byor cut to this weak side will put an end
cheaper and more efficient guns. Theto the charging swordsman. Though I
replacement of the elite warrior classhave used the spear here as the
by the gun was not a phenomenon knownswordsman's nemesis, one can see that
only to the Japanese. The gun in itsany weapon of greater length or weight
own time systematically brought aboutwould prove technologically superior.
the dismantling of the elite warriorIt becomes obvious why the swordsman's
classes worldwide. The Chinese Boxers,survival is so unlikely. The sword has
the Scots Highlanders, the Zulu, thecome to stand on a solid throne where
Aborigines, and the American Indiansits powers are more mythical than the
were among the last holdouts of thesword-wielding heroes themselves. We
warrior elite, and they all fell victimhave come to believe the sword and its
to the gun. For most of these warriorpowers as the staple of all the
cultures the sword became a symbolicclassical warrior societies. Swords
relic of an age far more romantic thenhave been given names and positions of
it actually was. Since the end of thepower; some were even believed to be
elite warrior classes the factsmagical. The right person with the
regarding the sword and its value as aright sword could smite injustice, slay
weapon have been exaggerated far andthe wicked, and restore kingdoms,
away beyond its real functions as anassuming that is no one else shows up
instrument of war. The sword haswith a spear, halberd, pole-flail, rake,
several weaknesses as a combat weapon.pitchfork, or sling. The entertainment
Due to its limited reach or in the caseindustry may keep the sword on a throne
of the great sword, excessive length;of power and awe, but for those who have
one has less time for reaction to anfought with and against the sword in all
opponent's attack. The sword's edge isits manifestations, it's a translucent
fragile and easily damaged so parriesand mythological throne. By Larry L
need to be made with the flat of theAndrews Find much more at spearduel.
blade, making defense both complicated



1 A B C D 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112